For $9.99 per month, Pier 1 offers Pier 1 Rewards, a loyalty
program that includes benefits such as a 10% discount on all
purchases and free shipping and returns on eligible items. Until
recently, when a consumer added an item to a cart, the company
would automatically also add the Pier 1 Rewards membership to the
cart (with a pre-checked box indicating acceptance) and apply the
10% discount. A consumer had to uncheck the box to remove the
membership from the cart.
NAD discovered this as part of their routine monitoring –
or routine shopping (it's hard to tell) – and had two
related concerns about what Pier 1 was doing. First, whether
advertising a discounted price for a product is misleading if it
reflects a discount that is only available with a subscription. And
second, whether Pier 1 clearly and conspicuously disclosed the
material terms of the subscription before a consumer made a
purchase decision.