Due to heightened scrutiny of diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives, many colleges and universities have been reviewing scholarship programs and other donor-restricted funds that include race- or gender-based eligibility criteria. To reduce potential legal risks, some institutions have considered replacing those criteria with eligibility requirements that do not reference protected characteristics. But this approach can raise questions regarding the extent to which institutions may or should modify criteria established by charitable donors, sometimes decades prior.
In June 2026, the Iowa Supreme Court issued one of the first judicial decisions touching on this open question, In re Ezra L. Totton Scholarship.1 The Court held that any modification of donor-restricted funds must remain consistent with the donor's charitable purposes. Compliance with US Supreme Court guidance (i.e., Students for Fair Admissions, Inc. v. President & Fellows of Harvard College (SFFA)2), the