Despite the existence - and admission into evidence - of the
client product manufacturer's self-critical analysis report,
including acknowledgment of a design defect of the product at
issue, Newark Managing Partner Colin P. Hackett obtained a verdict
less than 15% of Plaintiffs' settlement demand prior to trial.
The defense did make an in limine motion seeking to bar reference
to the client product manufacturer's report as a
"subsequent remedial measure", however, the trial court
ruled the report, including acknowledgment of a design defect of
the product at issue was admissible. The fact that the design
defect was subsequently remedied was not deemed admissable.
Although not entirely unanticipated, this ruling limited the
defense on the issue of liability. The following issues were
ultimately addressed by the jury: (1) Was the client
manufacturer's product defectively designed; (2) What, if any,
orthopedic injury did Plaintiff suffer, were they proximately
caused by