Judge permits schools, however, to offer additional
non-cash, education-related benefits.
The U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California
struck down, as antitrust law violations, certain NCAA rules that
limit student-athletes from receiving non-cash compensation and
benefits related to education. But in a significant victory for
those who oppose "pay-for-play" college sports, the court
upheld NCAA rules that limit compensation and benefits
unrelated to education, as well as rules that limit cash
awards for academic achievement or graduation.
Judge Claudia Wilken's 104-page order and accompanying
injunction was issued in In re: National Collegiate Athletic
Association Grant-in-Aid Cap Antitrust Litigation, which
includes the highly publicized Alston and Jenkins
cases. The class action lawsuit involves Division I football and
basketball student-athletes who alleged that the NCAA and 11
collegiate athletic conferences deprived them of compensation