A much-anticipated judgment of the Court of Appeal has been
handed down this morning that addresses the important issue of
whether a charterer's failure to pay hire amounts to a breach
of a condition, thereby giving rise to a right to terminate the
contract and claim damages for the remaining period of the
charter.
In Grand China Logistics Holding (Group) Co Ltd v Spar
Shipping AS [2016] EWCA Civ 982, the Court of Appeal has held
– contrary to the controversial 2013 decision of Flaux J in
The 'Astra' — that the failure to pay hire
(in this case under Clause 11 of NYPE 1993) does not amount to a
breach of condition.
The decision of the Court of Appeal returns English law to the
generally accepted position prior to The 'Astra',
namely that although the owner may often have a contractual right
to withdraw the vessel for non-payment of hire, it is also
necessary to establish a repudiatory breach on the part of the
charterer if the owner is to be able to recover