It has long been accepted that in Admiralty matters, expert evidence as to matters of seamanship is not admissible without the leave of the court. We take a look at the use of illustrative plotting in Admiralty cases involving collisions between ships, and some of the reasons for the Admiralty Court’s cautious approach to the use of reconstructions in its effort to assess what really happened.
In his judgment in The "Pelopidas" [1999] 2 Lloyd’s Rep 681, Steel J quoted from the judgment of Lord Sumner in The "Australian" [1927] A.C. at p.152 when emphasising that:
"in questions of nautical science and skill, relating to the management and movement of ships, a Court, assisted by nautical assessors, obtains the information from them, not from sworn witnesses called by the parties…"