1. This is the second short article in a series focusing on
lesser-known case law which may assist in defending claims brought
against highways authorities for failing to maintain the highway
under section 41 of the Highways Act 1980 and its predecessors.
2. In the early ‘Liverpool' cases, the Courts made
it clear that uneven pavements are an unfortunate vicissitude of
life, and nothing short of a real source of danger would suffice to
establish liability. Perhaps the best-known statement of principle
was found in the judgment of Cumming Bruce J in Littler v
Liverpool Corporation (1968) 2 All ER 343:
“A length of pavement is only dangerous if, in the
ordinary course of human affairs, danger may reasonably be
anticipated from its continued use by the public who usually pass
over it. It is a mistake to isolate and emphasise a particular
difference in levels between flagstones unless that difference is
such that a reasonable person who noticed and considered it