Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 07 JANUARY 2010

Engine And Component Cannibalisation: A Step Too Far?

Zohar Zik examines the court decision in U.S. Bank National Association v Southwest Airlines Company, which addresses potential pitfalls associated with the practice of substituting engines and parts of leased aircraft.

United KingdomTransport
Zohar Zik
Zohar Zik

Zohar Zik examines the court decision in U.S. Bank National Association v Southwest Airlines Company1, which addresses potential pitfalls associated with the practice of substituting engines and parts of leased aircraft. The implications of this decision give rise to a number of practical considerations, which are also discussed.

Key facts

In June 1987, Southwest Airlines Company ("Southwest") took three Boeing 737-3H4 aircraft (the "aircraft") on lease from U.S. Bank National Association (as successor owner trustee) ("BNA"). The aircraft were leased under three identical lease agreements (collectively referred to as the "lease"), which contained the following provisions:

1 Section 5(a) permitted replacement of engines provided that, at lease return, they were of equivalent utility and value and, when installed and used on the airframe, would not impair the value or utility of the aircraft. The section also provided that, at aircraft return, each replacement

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from