Three years on and the ramifications of the major cyber incident that affected genetic research company 23andMe in 2023 are still being felt, with the incident resulting in multi-jurisdictional regulatory fines and litigation. We compare the recent fine from the Spanish data protection authority (the AEPD) to the ICO’s 2025 fine in respect of the same incident, highlighting some key learnings about the differing regulatory approaches and the implications for handling global incidents.
Regulatory approach: ICO v AEPD
The UK and Spanish data regulators found similar underlying GDPR security failings (for example, credential stuffing attacks exploiting gaps in multi-factor authentication (MFA) and username/password-only authentication), and fined similar amounts (£2,31m in the UK and €2,4m in Spain, even though significantly more individuals were impacted in the UK). However, there were some differences in their approach: