Kate Prestidge, Solicitor & Richard West,
Partner
Claimants who exaggerate their claims risk serious
punishment.
Contempt of court is a serious offence and if someone is found
guilty of it, the penalties can be heavy. With the compensation
culture gathering speed, insurers and defendant solicitors are
increasingly aware of fraudulent and exaggerated claims. The recent
case of Kirk v Walton (2008) is a good example of such a
claim, and one where the defendant has won the first round. It is
an important precedent for both defendants and insurers alike, not
least because it shows that the courts are losing patience with
dishonest claimants.
Background Facts
On 10 August 2004, Joanne Kirk (who was 41 at the time of the
accident) was involved in a minor road traffic accident with Carol
Walton's vehicle. It was accepted that Ms Walton had been
driving negligently and liability was therefore not disputed. Mrs
Kirk sustained injuries from what she described as a