"In the two centuries which followed Lord
Mansfield's apparently simple proposition, it was among the
most heavily litigated rules of common law, and by the end of the
twentieth century it had become encrusted with an incoherent mass
of inconsistent authority."
Lord Sumption in Jetivia v Bilta [2015] UKSC
23
The rule referred to in the above quotation is commonly
expressed through the maxim: ex turpi causa non oritur
actio. Or, as Lord Mansfield put it in 1775: "No
court will lend its aid to a man who founds his cause of action
upon an immoral or an illegal act." It is the defence of
illegality.
There is currently a war in the Supreme Court over the very
foundation of the defence. Three battles have been fought in the
highest court of the land, with differently constituted benches
reaching seemingly inconsistent decisions. Before reviewing the
most recent judgments, however, it is helpful to remind ourselves
of the legal landscape as it stood before the most