In Individual Homes Limited v Macbream Investments Limited (The Times, 14 November 2002) the court closed a potential loophole in the Civil Procedure Rules (CPR) and confirmed its jurisdiction and discretion to award costs in favour of a non-party when that non-party has been compelled by witness summons to provide evidence to assist a party.
Background
The claimant, Individual Homes Limited, sought specific performance of an agreement for the sale and purchase of land. One of the issues in the case was whether the defendant, Macbream Investments Limited, was able to complete the transaction at the time it served a notice to complete on the claimant. The claimant alleged that the property was subject to a mortgage and that the mortgagee (Halifax Bank of Scotland plc (the Bank), which was not a party to the case) had not agreed to the sale and would not have agreed to discharge its mortgage to allow completion. To prove this, the claimant needed various documents held by the Bank.