What caught my eye about this judgment was the
comment about the need for expert evidence to establish breach of
duty in a lawyer's negligence case.
The claim was always going to be a tall order, alleging
negligence by leading firm Leigh Day, which had in turn instructed
eminent leading counsel, in its representation of a family at an
inquest. Mrs Justice Andrews dismissed the claim in
characteristically forthright terms.
At paragraphs 8 and 9 the judge said:
" It is not enough to show that a different solicitor
may have taken a different view or a different course, let alone
that the client felt that the solicitor could have done more. That
is why the court will rarely hold a professional to be in breach of
duty in the absence of assistance from a suitably qualified expert
who can explain why in his or her opinion the acts or omissions
complained of fell below the standard of professional competence
that would have been expected in those circumstances. No