Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 04 MARCH 2009

Claimants Behaving Badly

When might a defence based on the ex turpi or illegality principle be successful in a tort case? The ex turpi rule (or ex turpi causa non oritor actio, to give the principle its full name) is that no legal action based on illegality can succeed

United KingdomLitigation, Mediation & Arbitration
Mark Dickson, Partner
Mark Dickson, Partner

Does the illegality doctrine apply to tort claims?

When might a defence based on the ex turpi or illegality principle be successful in a tort case? The ex turpi rule (or ex turpi causa non oritor actio, to give the principle its full name) is that no legal action based on illegality can succeed.

For many years, the courts adopted a flexible approach to the principle in tort cases, as the seriousness of the illegality could vary. A public conscience test was developed. In Tinsley v Milligan (1993), the House of Lords applied a test based on reliance: did the claimant have to rely on their own illegality in order to pursue their claim? If so, the claim would fail. Tinsley was a property rights case, though. Two recent decisions have examined how far the Tinsley principle applies to tort claims.

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from