High Court & European Court of Justice Judgment European Court of Justice: 23 April 2002
The European Court of Justice has now given its Judgment in this case referred by Mr Justice Laddie of the High Court in the UK. The case concerned the repackaging of pharmaceutical parallel imports obtained from within the EU and in particular the circumstances in which the parallel importer is entitled to rebox rather than relabel pharmaceutical imports.
The ECJ clearly rejected Mr Justice Laddie’s primary proposition that a trade mark owner could only object to the repackaging of its products if it could prove that there was substantial harm to specific subject matter of the trade mark. Mr Justice Laddie had stated that it was only after such substantial harm had been proved that the Court needed to consider the guidelines set out in Bristol Myers Squib -v- Paranova.