Rylands v Fletcher1is one of the most iconic
judgments ever to have been handed down by an English court. It
established the principle that a person who brings something onto
his land which is likely to do mischief if it escapes, keeps it at
his peril and will be strictly liable for any damage caused by the
thing's escape. In Stannard (t/A Wyvern Tyres) v
Gore2, the Court of Appeal has given helpful
guidance on the application of the Rylands v Fletcher rule
to cases involving the escape of fire. Property and liability
insurers will be pleased to note that it applies only in very
restricted circumstances.
The background
Mr Stannard ran a business supplying and fitting tyres and
stored around 3,000 of them on his land. An electrical fire broke
out, which ignited the tyres. The fire spread rapidly, destroying
neighbouring premises owned by Mr Gore. Mr Gore brought a claim in
negligence and in strict liability.