Introduction:
As has been widely reported in recent weeks, the Supreme
Court's judgment in AXA General Insurance Limited &
others v The Lord Advocate & others ("the AXA
judgment") addresses several issues of constitutional
importance.
The AXA judgment upheld the lawfulness of the Damages
(Asbestos-Related Conditions) Scotland Act 2009 ("the
2009 Act"), allowing the payment of damages to sufferers of
pleural plaques, a scarring of the lungs caused by exposure to
asbestos. Perhaps more significantly from a constitutional
perspective, the AXA judgment also abolishes the "title and
interest" test in public law proceedings.
Background:
AXA and other leading insurers sought to challenge the 2009 Act
by way of a Judicial Review. The challenge was defended by
the Scottish Government, the Advocate General for Scotland and a
group of eight pleural plaques sufferers who wanted to support the
2009 Act. One of the arguments put forward on behalf of the
insurers was