Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 28 FEBRUARY 2006

Sowden One Year On - Who Is Footing The Bill?

Insurers dealing with catastrophic injury claims have seen a relentless rise in the level of damages awarded as claimants display ever-greater ingenuity in the formulation and presentation of claims. Sowden appeared to offer a means by which the care element of such claims might be reduced. How in practice are the courts reconciling the principle that the defendant should compensate for the loss which he has caused with the duty of local authorities to provide care for those in their area who ne

United KingdomInsurance
Charles Brown
Charles Brown

Originally published in The Insurance Law Quarterly: Winter 2005

Insurers dealing with catastrophic injury claims have seen a relentless rise in the level of damages awarded as claimants display ever-greater ingenuity in the formulation and presentation of claims. Sowden appeared to offer a means by which the care element of such claims might be reduced. How in practice are the courts reconciling the principle that the defendant should compensate for the loss which he has caused with the duty of local authorities to provide care for those in their area who need it?

The Sowden/Crookdake principles

In Sowden the defendant achieved a substantial saving as a result of the contribution to the claimant’s care costs made by the local authority. Although the onus is on a defendant to prove that local authority provision is adequate and meets the claimant’s reasonable needs, the Court of Appeal concluded that if this is achieved, then a claim for private care costs will fail. Further, if

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from