In the recent Court of Appeal decision in Drake v Provident (2003), the Court once again had to consider the extent to which the duty of good faith continued post contract, this time from the insurer’s stand point.
The facts in Drake are so full of twists and turns they could have stepped straight out of a Bar Finals exam. At risk of oversimplification, however, the case involved an attempt by an insurance company to avoid a motor policy. The insured had renewed his motor policy without declaring on the proposal form a speeding conviction which he had picked up in the previous year.
Further, the proposal form had also incorrectly declared a separate incident (incurred by the insured’s wife who was a named driver on the policy) as a "fault" accident. This was a carry-on from the previous year’s proposal but subsequently the accident had been recatagorised as a "no fault" accident. The significance of this was that the combination of a "fault accident" and a speeding conviction would