The Competitive Dialogue Procedure has only been around for
three years now, but HM Treasury have recently launched a review of
the procedure and, in many people's view, the review has been a
long time in coming.
Unlike the negotiated, open and restricted procedures,
competitive dialogue is aimed at more complex procurements such as
PFI/PPP projects and aims to increase the bidders'
understanding of requirements, increase openness between the public
and private sector and promote competitive tension.
However, competitive dialogue has not been without its problems.
Concerns have been raised, for example, over the increased costs
for bidders, the unnecessary time delays in reaching preferred
bidder stage, and the overall uncertainty on application of the
rules. Despite having been used more than 1200 times in three
years, the stringent implementation of the competitive dialogue
procedure in the UK has been criticised by the partnerships
industry in particular, who