Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 01 JULY 2011

When Is An Employee Not An Employee?

Answer: When he is a self-employed contractor. This is far from being a top class joke – a Christmas cracker gag is likely to raise a bigger smile. However, what sets this poor joke apart from others is that the punch-line was delivered by the Court of Appeal.

United KingdomEmployment and HR
Paul Gaff
Paul Gaff

Answer: When he is a self-employed contractor.

This is far from being a top class joke – a Christmas cracker gag is likely to raise a bigger smile. However, what sets this poor joke apart from others is that the punch-line was delivered by the Court of Appeal. It was no laughing matter for Mr Tilson because not only did he lose his job but his unfair dismissal claim failed as well.

Alstom Transport ("Alstom") provides railway services and Mr Tilson started working for them in August 2004 as a Technical Engineer and he was subsequently promoted to manager level. While working for Alstom, Mr Tilson was fully integrated into its business because he was supervised by its managers. He had to apply to his line manager to take holiday and he had managerial responsibility for Alstom staff.

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from