The recent High Court case of Lonmar Global Risks Limited v West
& Others is a salutary tale for insurance brokers faced with
one of their teams moving to a direct competitor.
The three defendant employees worked for Lonmar until mid-2009
when, with others, they left; each was summarily dismissed by
Lonmar on the basis that they had, by their conduct, committed a
repudiatory breach of their employment contract. This conduct
included soliciting clients and other employees of Lonmar and
taking steps to move work and employees away from Lonmar, largely
to a direct competitor, Tyser, to which the three employees
subsequently moved.
Lonmar claimed damages of approximately £2.5 million against
the three employees for breach of contract and breach of fiduciary
duty and against the three employees and Tyser for inducing
breaches of contract and conspiracy. The judge concluded that
Lonmar had not suffered any loss arising from the employees' or
Tyser's actions and that