What does an employer or insurer have to do, in
cases of suspected suicide, to determine if death in service
benefits are payable? Establishing the cause of death can give rise
to complex issues such as those explored in a recent case involving
a marine crew fatality. The matter of Braganza v BP Shipping Ltd
(2015) revolved around the disappearance of Mr Braganza while
working as chief engineer on an oil tanker managed by BP Shipping
Ltd (BP).
This article first appeared in
Clyde & Co Shipping Newsletter – July 2015.
BP's investigation
BP, the employer, was contractually liable to pay compensation
for the death of its employees unless, in its opinion, the loss was
by "wilful default" (i.e. suicide). BP concluded that the
most likely explanation for the disappearance was that the deceased
had committed suicide by throwing himself overboard. BP reached its
conclusion after conducting a safety investigation into how its
systems could be improved to prevent such