The City of Oxford Bus Services Ltd t/a Oxford Bus Company v
Harvey involved an indirect religious discrimination claim.
The EAT had to decide whether the tribunal had approached the
employer's justification defence correctly and found that it
had not. The tribunal had focussed on the impact of the requirement
for Saturday working on the individual and had not taken the wider
business circumstances into account.
The employer operated bus services in Oxford. Its rostering
arrangements required all bus drivers to work five days a week,
including at least one day at the weekend. As a Seventh Day
Adventist, Mr Harvey could not work between sunset on Friday and
sunset on Saturday and brought a claim that the rostering
requirements placed him at a disadvantage because of his religious
beliefs. The tribunal rejected the employer's argument that the
requirement was justified as a proportionate means of achieving
legitimate aims of efficiency, fairness to all staff, a