The difficulties in succeeding in a direct disability
discrimination claim are illustrated by the Court of Appeal
decision in Owen v Amec Foster Wheeler Energy
Ltd.
Mr Owen was a chemical engineer who had been working on a
project. The client wanted him to transfer to Dubai to work on the
second stage of the project. Candidates for overseas assignments
were required to undertake a medical assessment. However, Mr
Owen's various medical conditions, including poorly controlled
diabetes, renal impairment and heart disease, meant that his
assignment to an overseas location was viewed as high risk and he
was not deployed. He claimed direct disability discrimination,
indirect discrimination and failure to make reasonable adjustments.
All claims failed in the tribunal and EAT and Mr Owen appealed to
the Court of Appeal.