Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 29 JULY 2013

Limits To "Business Common Sense" Interpretation

Charles Russell Speechlys LLP
Charles Russell Speechlys LLP
Contributor
Charles Russell Speechlys LLP

Charles Russell Speechlys LLP

Charles Russell Speechlys is an international law firm with a focus on private capital, at the...

View firm profile
Explore more from Charles Russell Speechlys LLP

The "business common sense" test should only be applied where there is a genuine ambiguity.

United KingdomCorporate/Commercial Law

The case concerned liability to pay a prepayment fee under a loan facility agreement where a borrower refinanced the loan and used the proceeds to repay the amount outstanding. The detailed and heavily negotiated facility agreement set out the circumstances in which the loan could be repaid. Clause 8.3 provided for a compulsory repayment upon a refinancing; clause 8.5 covered voluntary repayment. The prepayment fee was due only on a voluntary repayment.

The Court of Appeal held that no prepayment fee was due. On the facts, it was clear that the prepayment circumstances in clause 8 were intended to be mutually exclusive and that the refinancing gave rise to a compulsory prepayment under clause 8.3. The fact that the refinancing had been voluntary did not mean that the prepayment itself was voluntary. This meant that no prepayment fee was payable.

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from