The need for urgent reform of court reporting in child fatality
prosecutions
The recent decision of the Court of Appeal in
DPP and E.C. and Media Outlets [2020] IECA
292 highlights a section of the Children Act, 2001
which urgently needs legislative amendment to cure an anomaly which
has lain dormant until now.
Children Act, 2001
The essence of the application before the Court of Appeal was
whether a person charged with the death a child could be
identified, given the provisions of Section 252 (1) of the Children
Act, 2001, the purpose of which is to protect the identity of a
child who has allegedly been the victim of a crime. The need to
protect the identity of a living child victim is apparent and
uncontroversial. However, in the case of a deceased child, the
question is whether the accused should benefit from the provision
which is intended to protect the child, not the accused.