Share on LinkedInShare on LinkedIn

ARTICLE · 16 JANUARY 2014

No Two Sides To The Story Until The Second Side Is Heard

A recent decision of the Supreme Court has reinforced the need for a trial court to consider a plaintiff’s evidence at its best before concluding that there is no case for a defendant to answer in evidence. This case will be of relevance to defendants and their insurers in professional negligence actions in determining whether to make an application for a ‘non-suit’ at the end of a plaintiff’s evidence, to dismiss the claim for failure to make out a ‘prima facie’ case. Murphy v Callaghan invo

IrelandLitigation, Mediation & Arbitration

A recent decision of the Supreme Court has reinforced the need for a trial court to consider a plaintiff's evidence at its best before concluding that there is no case for a defendant to answer in evidence. This case will be of relevance to defendants and their insurers in professional negligence actions in determining whether to make an application for a 'non-suit' at the end of a plaintiff's evidence, to dismiss the claim for failure to make out a 'prima facie' case.

Murphy v Callaghan involved an elderly plaintiff who had transferred her property into the joint names of herself and her grandson, and then sold the property. The proceeds of sale were sent by way of cheque payable to both the plaintiff and her grandson, whose name was the same as the plaintiff's son. The plaintiff's son lodged the cheque in his own account. The plaintiff brought a professional negligence action against her solicitors and sued her son and grandson but settled with each of them.

We operate a free-to-view policy, asking only that you register in order to read all of our content. Please login or register to view the rest of this article.

See more popular content from