The Irish Supreme Court has significantly treated concessions by
An Bord Pleanála to orders of certiorari on grants of
planning permission as opinion only, thus enabling developers to
continue to defend judicial review challenges, in certain
circumstances.
Background to the case
Ballyboden Tidy Towns Group, issued judicial review proceedings
seeking to quash a decision of An Bord Pleanála ('the
Board') dated July 2021 granting planning permission to
Ardstone Homes ('Ardstone') for a Strategic Housing
Development ('SHD') of 241 apartments, between four and six
stories high, at Stocking Avenue, Woodstown, Dublin 16.
The Board subsequently indicated in May 2022 that it was
conceding the judicial review challenge on the basis that it
accepted it had failed to assess whether there was adequate public
transport capacity for the proposed development, in material
contravention of the Urban Development and Building Height
Guidelines.