Expert evidence required to proceed in professional medical
negligence action
Abigail Barnett Hunt v Peter Gormley, Bon Secours Health
Systems Limited and Bon Secours Hospital Galway [2019] IEHC 316 (16
May 2019)
The High Court (Barrett J.) dismissed an application by the
plaintiff for judgment in default of defence against Bon Secours
Health Systems Limited (Bon Secours Health) and
Bon Secours Hospital Galway (Bon Secours
Hospital), on the grounds that it appeared that the
plaintiff had not obtained an independent expert report in relation
to the treatment provided by them.
Facts
In this case the plaintiff alleged negligence and breach of duty
by Bon Secours Health and Bon Secours Hospital. Solicitors for
those defendants wrote to the plaintiff's solicitors asking if
they had obtained an independent expert report which specifically
criticised the treatment provided by their clients as opposed to
the first named defendant, Mr. Gormley. They did not receive