Crocs Inc. is a popular U.S. brand known for its unusual clog
like footwear which may have a perforated or a non-perforated
surface design. It is for this reason that Croc Inc obtained design
registration for both its usual designs. This was followed by Croc
Inc. filing multiple suits against its competitors such as Liberty,
Relaxo, Action Shoes, Bata etc. to injunct them from selling
footwear which were identical/imitation of Croc's registered
design. Initially, Croc succeeded in obtaining an interim
injunction in these cases however, the injunction orders were later
vacated. These matters were heard together and recently, the Delhi
High Court passed its judgment.
The Plaintiff (Crocs) claimed that the defendants (Liberty,
Bata, Action Shoes etc.) were infringing on its statutory rights
under Section 11 of the Designs Act, 2000 and therefore, it ought
to be protected under Section 22 of the Act. The defendants argued
that the Plaintiff's design was liable to be