When an application for a patent is made at the Indian Patent
office ("IPO") by virtue of an assignment of the right to
apply, the IPO requires the submission of the proof of right. It
has been observed that most applicants did not follow the practice
of filing the proof of right and generally, no objections were
raised by the IPO especially in cases of Convention
applications
However, the IPO raised an objection regarding the proof of
right in the examination report of Application No.794/CHE/2006 and
it was held that the applicant had failed to fulfill the
requirements of the Indian Patents Act, 1970 ("the Act")
by not obtaining the signatures from the inventors on Form 1 or by
not filing the assignment deed from the inventors or any other
documents in support of their right to make the application in
India. The order was appealed and the Intellectual Property
Appellate Board (IPAB) in its order of 28th October, 2013 in
NTT DoCoMo v Controller of Patents held that