Can the Controller of Designs refuse to register a design for
lacking novelty after the applicant deletes some representations of
the design on the recommendation of the examiner? A recent decision
of the Calcutta High Court points out that an examination report
only facilitates the controller's final decision, and concludes
that a design application can be refused registration even after it
is amended. The decision also clarifies the role of the examiner
and controller in the design registration process.
The design application in this case (Simon vs The Controller of
Patent and Designs, AID 2 of 2018, AID 3 of 2018 and AID 4 of 2018,
Calcutta High Court, 27 September 2018) pertained to certain
"Accessories For Electrical Devices", claiming priority
from a Spanish design application. The application was received in
May 2012, and was forwarded by the controller for examination. The
First Examination Report arrived in January 2013, in which the
examiner suggested that