During the last decade, India has seen an increasing trend of
judicial scrutiny of Public-Private Partnership (PPP) contracts in
an attempt to strike a balance between public-interest and
interests of private parties. What once lay in the ostensibly
private realm of a “commercial bargain” is fast
becoming subject to rigorous public-law standards, particularly
where the contract involves public assets, monopoly rights, or
statutory delegations. The Supreme Court's in its recent
decision inNOIDA Toll Bridge Company Ltd. v. Federation
of NOIDA Residents Welfare Association (2024 INSC
1027) reinforced and upheld the decision of the
Hon'ble Allahabad High Court to remove levy of Toll on the
Delhi-NOIDA Direct Flyway (DND Flyway) in public interest. While
the judgment calls into question pattern of cost inflation, lack of
transparency in delegation of taxing powers, and significant
profits to the concessionaire, it also raises the most important
question about the limits of