Singapore courts addressed the intra‑EU objection to investor‑State arbitration for the first time, rejecting Achmea and Komstroy challenges and aligning with English, Swiss and Australian courts
In two decisions handed down in early 2026, the Singapore courts addressed – for the first time – the intra‑EU objection to investor‑State arbitration. In rejecting the Achmea- and Komstroy-based challenges, the Singapore courts adopted an approach that aligns closely with the prevailing practice of English, Swiss and Australian courts.
In DNZ v DOA and another [2026] SGHC(I) 1, the Singapore International Commercial Court (SICC) rejected an EU Member State’s attempt to set aside an Energy Charter Treaty (ECT) award on the basis that Article 26 of the ECT was inapplicable to intra‑EU disputes. Shortly thereafter, in NextEra Energy Global Holdings BV and another v Kingdom of Spain [2026] SGHC 43, the General Division of the High Court also rejected EU‑law‑based objections raised in