1. Key takeaways
Preservation of evidence: alignment between Claimant’s representatives and the expert before seizure does not affect impartiality
One defendant requested that an expert report submitted to the Judge Rapporteur at the end of seizure measures and the inspection of the defendant’s premises be declared null and void. They argued that there had been a preparatory meeting of the expert with the claimant, which seemed to have influenced the expert in the claimant’s favour.
At the outset, the LD finds that it has jurisdiction to decide this issue.
However, the LD points out that, for efficiency reasons, seizure measures have to be prepared in advance, which includes getting in touch with the claimant’s representatives (being the only party in the present ex parte procedure). In the LD’s opinion, this does not cast doubt on the expert’s impartiality. In any case, the expert had, according to the court, ample opportunity to take note of the defendant’s arguments when