In its judgment delivered on 17 September 2015 in van der
Lans v KLM, the Court of Justice of the EU held that the
'extraordinary circumstances' defence (which relieves a
carrier of its obligation to pay compensation in respect of a
cancelled or delayed flight under Regulation (EC) 261/2004) does
not apply in the case of an unexpected technical problem which is
not attributable to poor maintenance and was not discovered during
routine maintenance.
The facts
Ms van der Lans held a ticket for carriage with KLM from Quito
(Ecuador) to Amsterdam (Netherlands). During pushback it was
discovered that one of the aircraft's engines would not start
due to a lack of fuel feed. KLM's investigations revealed that
the issue was caused by a problem with two separate engine
components. The aircraft did not depart until the following day,
with Ms van der Lans suffering a twenty-nine hour delay on arrival
as a result.