The Beijing Intellectual
Property Court has reversed a decision of the China National
Intellectual Property Administration (CNIPA) and invalidated a
third-party registration of a graphic representation of Bulgari Co.
Ltd's 'snake head' design.
On 28 April 2019, CNIPA
ruled that the evidence submitted by Bulgari Co. Ltd (Bulgari) was
not sufficient to prove that it owned copyright in the 'snake
head' graphic: registration of the trade mark in dispute had
not violated Article 32 of the 2014 Trademark
Law. Bulgari then filed an administrative lawsuit with
the Beijing Intellectual Property Court.
The Beijing Intellectual
Property Court found that Bulgari's 'snake head'
graphics constituted original artistic works for the purposes of
China's copyright law. Further, the evidence in the case proved
that Bulgari had enjoyed copyright in the works prior to the date
of application for registration of the trade mark in dispute, and
had publicised and used the works on