On September 17, 2018, Justice Coroza of the Ontario Superior
Court of Justice released his decision in Bucknol v. 2280882
Ontario Inc1(“Bucknol”), a
motion for summary judgement dealing with commercial host liability
and outlining the pillars of claims of negligence. Interestingly,
Justice Coroza originally heard the motion in January of 2018 and
reserved his decision. In June of 2018, counsel for the defendant
(moving party) brought to his Honour's attention the May 2018
Supreme Court of Canada decision of Rankin (Rankin's Garage
& Sales) v. J.J (“Rankin”) and
further written submissions were requested of counsel.
By way of background in Bucknol, the plaintiff was
struck by a beer bottle that had been thrown by an unknown
assailant at Classic Lounge Nightclub (“Classic”) in
May 2012. Shortly after the incident, the plaintiff left the
premises to seek medical attention but did so without alerting any
of the staff or security at Classic. The plaintiff sustained