The Supreme Court of British Columbia (BCSC)
recently released judgment in Ding v. GSV Futures Inc., 2022 BCSC
1921, which offers a useful precedent for bitcoin and other
cryptocurrency mining agreements, specifically highlighting the
importance of a properly drafted liquidated damages clause. In this
decision, E. McDonald J. ruled that a properly drafted contractual
to determine the liquidated damages in bitcoin is enforceable and
will not be interpreted as a penalty.
Background
Bei Ding (the Plaintiff), entered into a
bitcoin mining contract with GSV Futures Inc.
(GSV) in September 2021, whereby GSV promised to
provide Plaintiff with hosting services at GSV's mining
facility in Canada in exchange for certain payments. This contract
included a one-page supplemental agreement which set out the
theoretical profit calculation method for Plaintiff: