In Del Giudice v
Thompson,1 Perell J. of the Ontario
Superior Court of Justice denied the plaintiffs'
certification motion seeking certification of a class action
involving claims for data misappropriation and misuse stemming from
the 2019 Capital One data breach. This decision provides important
insights on how the court considers privacy cases, in particular
those involving third-party hackers, and the reluctance of the
court to find defendants in breach of a privacy tort for the
conduct of a third party.
BACKGROUND
The proposed class action arose after the defendant, Paige
Thompson, hacked the database of personal information collected by
Capital One. The Capital One data was stored on the computer
servers of Amazon Web Services, of which Thompson had previously
been an employee. Ms. Thompson went on to misappropriate the data
by posting it on the website GitHub, a forum for software
developers to share information.