Karasik v. Yahoo
In the recent decision of Justice Perell in Karasik v. Yahoo Inc., a motion by
the representative plaintiffs for production of Yahoo's
Canadian user database was dismissed. While Perell J. applied
well-established principles in reaching this conclusion, the motion
illustrates the rule that documentary production prior to
certification will be limited within the confines of being
proportionate, relevant and necessary to certification itself.
By way of background, in 2016 several representative plaintiffs
commenced a proposed class action against Yahoo advancing privacy
torts and certain statutory claims arising from large data breaches
that occurred in 2013, 2014 and 2016. It was widely believed
that the Russian state security service was responsible for the
cyber-attacks that compromised Yahoo user accounts worldwide.