The Divisional Court recently upheld a trial decision finding
that an employer did not defame a former employee when it gave him
a bad reference.
The Facts
The employee in Papp v. Stokes was
terminated by his employer, and subsequently asked whether he could
list them as a reference when applying for new employment. His
former employer agreed. The employee submitted applications and was
ranked first among candidates for a job with a new employer. The
new employer asked for his references before making a formal offer,
and so the employee contacted his former employer to let them know
they would be receiving a call.
At some point after agreeing to act as a reference, his former
employer discovered that there had been issues with the
employee's performance that had not previously come to light.
His co-workers complained that he was difficult to work with and
did not get along with others on the team because he saw himself as
superior. The former employer conveyed