In a recent decision,1 the Superior Court of
Québec held that an authority cannot keep copies of
electronic documents seized during a search and seizure after
officially notifying the person that it will not bring penal or
administrative proceedings against the person. In this decision,
the Court reminds us that a seizing authority that retains a copy
of seized documents indefinitely without any form of judicial
review infringes the fundamental rights of the individuals whose
property was seized.
Background
During searches and seizures conducted as part of an
investigation involving 10 individuals and three companies, the
Autorité des marchés financiers (AMF) obtained close
to 16 million electronic documents, seizing computers, cellphones,
external hard drives and USB keys. Orders were rendered during the
course of the investigation to allow the AMF to keep what was
seized for a specified amount of time before charges were laid.
Three years after seizing the