On December 3, 2012 the Québec Court of Appeal rendered
its decision in the case of Schmidt v. Johnson & Johnson
Inc. 2012 QCCA 2132
("Schmidt"), in which it
formally nuanced Québec's so-called
"first-to-file" rule under which the first lawyer to file
a class action alleging a given cause of action against a defendant
would receive carriage of the matter over all similar class actions
filed subsequently. This rule had arisen in order to efficiently
deal with competing class actions filed by different plaintiff law
firms, a common occurrence in highly publicized cases. In many
other Canadian provinces, the issue of competing class actions is
dealt with by carriage motions, where the competing law firms
battle for carriage of the file by convincing a court that they are
the most competent and experienced, and that their proceedings are
the most comprehensive and clearest formulation of all the
potential claims on behalf of the class.