The Court of Appeal's recent decision in Live
Nation Ontario Concerts GP, Inc. v. Aviva Insurance Company of
Canada, 2024 ONCA 634 provides
clarity on the extent of an insurer's duty to defend in
relation to covered and uncovered claims brought against an insured
in an underlying action.
What you need to know
This decision is significant for litigants with large,
self-insured retentions, such as municipalities, who may frequently
seek a defence from insurers where they have been added as
additional insureds.
Previous Court of Appeal jurisprudence has held that multiple
insurers may need to respond to an insured's request for a
defence if there are multiple responding policies. In seeking
contribution from a co-insurer, an insurer can rely on the doctrine
of equitable contribution. However, equitable contribution can only
be sought from a concurrent insurer, not from an insured. The
existence of an insured's self-insured retention under a policy
does not turn