In Asfar v. Sun Life, Justice
Nakatsuru of the Ontario Superior Court of Justice granted summary
judgment in favour of the defendant and dismissed the
plaintiffs' claim on the basis that the plaintiffs discovered
that they had a claim against the defendant nearly 10 years prior
to commencing their action. In particular, the court considered the
fact that the plaintiffs threatened the defendant with a class
action and therefore understood that they had potentially suffered
loss or damage at the hands of the defendant.
Facts
The plaintiffs, Mr. Jean-Pierre Asfar and Equity Cheque Card
Corporation Ltd. (ECCC), commenced an action in April of 2018
against Sun Life for a host of issues relating to five mortgages by
Sun Life, the last of which discharged in 2006. In the Statement of
Claim, the plaintiffs attacked the various aspects of the mortgage
process, the conditions of the mortgage, the fees and interest
charged, and the profits made by Sun Life. The plaintiffs