Introduction and factual setting
To some extent this paper is a case comment on Hemmings v
Peng.1 More particularly, it focuses on the issue
of remoteness of damage (now generally referred to as "legal
causation") in the context of a medical malpractice
claim.2
The plaintiff in Hemmings was a 29-year-old woman who
suffered a cardiac arrest on the operating table during a Caesarian
section, as a result of which she sustained severe brain damage.
The plaintiff was morbidly obese, which made her a higher risk
patient. The C-section procedure began, in accordance with normal
practice, under a regional anesthetic, but the anesthetist decided
to convert to a general anesthetic after the plaintiff started to
panic and flail about and could not be calmed. The infant was
delivered some 8 to 11 minutes into general anesthesia, but shortly
after delivery the plaintiff experienced cardiac arrest and brain
damage ensued.