Sometimes the most efficient way to defeat a defamation claim is
to prove the defence of justification—namely, that the
impugned statements that are alleged to be defamatory were
substantially true.
The decision in Bell v. GRFN, 2022 ONSC 5603
(CanLII), involved a claim for defamation by a councillor of a
First Nation band against the First Nation's council, which was
responsible for administration, policing, and inter-governmental
relations, amongst other things.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, the First Nation, like other
public entities, had to deal with the financial implications of the
pandemic. The plaintiff councillor took issue with the financial
disclosure produced during the council's budget process. In
October 2021, the plaintiff posted a statement on Facebook which
stated, in part: "During the last term I had requested a
number of times our Financial Statements and a budget. For the last
year we have seen nothing". There was no question that by
"we,"