In its recent decision in Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis Society of Essex
County v. Windsor (City), the Ontario Court of
Appeal has held that the deemed undertaking rule does not apply to
opt-out information in a class proceeding.
During the opt out period of this class action, the defendants
embarked upon a public campaign to encourage putative class members
to opt out. After the class actions judge held that the defendants
had unduly influenced the opt-out process, a reconsideration period
was ordered to allow members to opt back in. Concerned that the
identity of those who had already opted out could be used by the
defendants to convince them to stay opted-out, the class actions
judge granted a protection order barring defendants' counsel
from divulging the number and identity of class members to their
respective clients. After the protection order was lifted, the
plaintiffs argued that the deemed undertaking rule prevent
defendants' counsel from disclosing to their